Verified permit record

Current Status

This page separates the latest agency action, the latest applicant filing, the current applicant deadline, and any verified public date.

Dates can change with a later filing or agency action. There is no countdown here. Check the official record before relying on a date.

Current Status

District issued an October 21 Clarification Letter; the application remains Incomplete

On October 21, 2026, SWFWMD issued a Clarification Letter on Application 930235 listing 14 required items. The letter says the application still lacks components needed to complete review. As of the November 6, 2026 verify, the SWFWMD public viewer still listed Application 930235 / ERP 47575.002 as Incomplete, with blank completeness and denied dates and no permit approval shown. No document typed as a Clarification response was posted; later documents include E-mail Records dated October 23 and November 2, 2026.

Clarification requested
Application
930235

Brooker Creek Mitigation Bank

Permit identifier
47575.002
Last agency action
October 21, 2026

SWFWMD Clarification Letter from Todd Boyle and Lee Hughes. The letter lists 14 required items covering cost estimates, planting and UMAM scoring, survey, title and easement errors, legal interest, title-exception language, and a fee title holder that is not an applicant.

Recent applicant-side documents
September 18–21, 2026

After the September 16 verify, the Documents tab listed RAI/CLAR Partial Responses (September 18 and 21), a Response to RAI (September 21), and an RAI/CLAR Supplemental (September 21). These are listed by document type and date only. No Clarification response to the October 21 letter was posted as of November 6, 2026.

Clarification response window
About January 19, 2027

The letter says the response must be received within 90 days from the date of the request (about January 19, 2027). It states that failure to provide the information within 90 days will delay processing and may result in denial, and that the applicant may make a written request for a time extension with acceptable justification. This is not a public hearing or petition deadline.

Next project-specific public date
None verified

No next project-specific public meeting, hearing, or public-comment date has been verified.

Last verified
November 6, 2026

Checked against the SWFWMD public viewer (warehouse as of November 6, 2026, 1:10 PM). Stale-data threshold: 7 days. Source access dates are listed below.

What changed: SWFWMD issued an October 21 Clarification Letter with 14 required items and a 90-day response window. What did not: as of November 6, 2026, SWFWMD had made no completeness determination and had not approved the permit. Always check the official record.

The 14 required items in the October 21, 2026 Clarification Letter

Agency requests, summarized from the letter signed by Todd Boyle, Staff Engineer, and Lee Hughes, P.W.S., Mitigation Bank Lead, addressed to GreenSource Environmental Professionals, Inc. (Attn: Ryan Deibler). These are District requests, not District findings on the merits. Read the letter on the official record’s Documents tab.

  • Cost estimates (items 1 and 11): the “total cost” column of the construction and implementation estimate was cut off and must be legible; a detailed written cost estimate in current dollars of construction and implementation and of perpetual management must be certified by an appropriately licensed professional. The letter says the provided estimates do not appear to be signed or sealed.
  • Planting and UMAM (items 2–4): move Thalia geniculata to Zone 3 on the Typical Pond Planting Section; submit completed Part I and II UMAM forms after scores are finalized; and contact Lee Hughes to discuss proposed UMAM scores for Golf Course Enhance to Pine Mesic Oak (Core), Ditch Restore to Wetland Forested Mixed, and Pond Restore to Freshwater Marsh, and the bank’s proposed site security measures. Revisions may be required after that meeting.
  • Survey, title, and easement errors (items 5–10): distance calls that do not match the DC Johnson Survey Curve Table, a scrivener’s error in Title Commitment Exhibit “A” Parcel 1, uncorrected bad bearings in the Title Commitment, the Conservation Easement legal description, the Draft Conservation Easement Exhibit B, and the Boundary Survey description, a Brooker Creek Access Easement missing Exhibit A, and an Access Easement on the Boundary Survey with no dimensions noted.
  • Legal interest (item 12): demonstrate that the applicant has sufficient legal interest in the project area to meet Rule 62-342.650, F.A.C.
  • Title exceptions (item 13): submit an updated Mitigation Plan providing, for Exception Nos. 5–8, 12, 21, 26, and 31 in the July 14, 2026 Title Commitment, that the District will be notified of any damage and the area returned to a substantially similar condition.
  • Fee title holder (item 14): Schedule A of the conservation-easement and access-easement title commitments lists two fee title holders, one of which, Jan Stephenson’s Crossroads Foundation, Inc., is not an applicant. The letter asks the applicant to add this entity as an applicant or remove the reference from the title commitment.

Sources and access dates

Opposition review of the applicants’ filing

They filed 121 pages. The unresolved questions are now easier to see.

Save Tarpon Woods campaign analysis—not an agency finding. We oppose converting this neighborhood landscape into a private wetland-credit bank. The applicants’ August 26 response does not change that position. It gives SWFWMD more material to review, but filing a response does not prove the proposal meets the permitting standards.

What the applicants now propose

  • 37.88 mitigation credits, with approximately 81% attributed to upland supporting habitat.
  • No earthwork, while proposing pond-to-marsh and ditch-to-forested-wetland restoration.
  • Signs, cameras, and limited fencing first, with possible additional fencing later.
  • Release of 60% of the credits before an interim ecological success level is demonstrated.

What remains unresolved

  • The applicants say the deed transfer and recordation are still in process.
  • No current FWC letter or current project-wide wildlife survey was supplied.
  • The success table contains vegetation targets but no measurable wetland hydroperiod or water-level criteria.
  • The work plan expects 75 pine trees per acre while the cost table funds 40 per acre.
  • The cost package contains an apparent Year 15 arithmetic error and no visible professional certification.

Applicant filing reviewed as of September 16, 2026; public docket re-verified November 6, 2026. The observations above are campaign analysis; SWFWMD had not posted a completeness determination or permit approval as of November 6. The District’s October 21 Clarification Letter now formally requests certified, signed-and-sealed cost estimates, a demonstration of sufficient legal interest, and reconciliation of Jan Stephenson’s Crossroads Foundation, Inc. being listed as a fee title holder but not as an applicant.

The useful status summary above works without JavaScript.

Campaign correspondence · October 8; receipt confirmed October 9

Emergency flood notice is in the official file; technical requests remain unanswered.

William R. Nobles, Jr. sent an emergency supplemental notice after reporting Brooker Creek outside its normal channel and preserving provisional USGS readings from the same rain event. The notice requests preservation, field inspection, watershed-scale hydraulic modeling, datum reconciliation, floodway no-rise and drainage-capacity analysis, and independent peer review before floodway-connected disturbance.

On October 9, SWFWMD General Counsel Christopher A. Tumminia confirmed that the District received and reviewed the October 8 notice and prior Save Tarpon Woods submissions and placed them in Application 930235’s file of record. He stated that the application remains under review and that any agency action will include notice of Chapter 120 rights.

Status boundary: the acknowledgment is not agency action and does not update the separately verified permit-status summary above. It does not state whether the requested field inspection, event-specific preservation, or additional hydraulic review will occur. The flood event does not prove that an unbuilt project caused flooding.

September 2 campaign accountability package

Additional campaign concerns now supplement the August 27 challenge.

Save Tarpon Woods campaign position—not an agency finding. The supplemental formal demand preserves every issue in the August 27 letter and adds the exact deadline chronology, the recovered 102-document Application 907654 docket, the current survey and Schedule B questions, County records DRM-23-00102 and DRM-24-00066, the homeowner floodway-modeling comparison, targeted environmental-history review, fee accounting, and preservation demands covering all three applications.

Procedural accountability

  • Identify the authority and facts supporting the post-date extension.
  • Explain why time “in-house” appeared in the recommendation.
  • Preserve emails, metadata, drafts, messages, routing, notes, and approval records.
  • Use an independent reviewer outside the immediate approval chain.

Technical accountability

  • Reconcile all three application designs, acreages, credits, structures, and earthwork.
  • Overlay floodway, floodplain, easements, work areas, credit polygons, and access.
  • Require current wildlife, hydrology, planting, soil, title, cost, and financial-assurance support.
  • Fund correction, default, and perpetual management before credit release.

Evidence boundary: No reviewed record establishes improper motive or misconduct. The request for independent review concerns procedure, consistency, documentation, and whether the same standards were applied to similarly situated applicants.

Resident public-comment letter

What we are asking SWFWMD to investigate before this permit moves forward

Save Tarpon Woods campaign position—not an agency finding. The letter does not ask SWFWMD to assume that every feared outcome will occur. It asks the District to identify foreseeable failure modes, require evidence-based answers, and attach enforceable remedies before the applicants may receive or sell mitigation credits.

Map what exists and what would earn credit

  • Put the 172.46-acre boundary, existing wetlands, every proposed credit polygon, uplands, access routes, and the effective FEMA regulatory floodway on one controlling signed and sealed survey.
  • Require the applicants to demonstrate incremental functional gain under UMAM and mitigation-bank rules without counting existing ecological function or existing regulatory protection as new gain.
  • Reconcile every acre so wetland, upland-support, preservation, buffer, and floodway values are not counted twice.

Explain every ground disturbance

  • Reconcile the assertion of “no earthwork” with ditch work, planting, thinning, removals, fencing, monitoring equipment, access, and well or utility work.
  • Identify the number and size of more than 60,000 proposed plants, planting-hole and root-ball dimensions, equipment routes, displaced soil and biomass, and where excess material would go.
  • Demonstrate that work will not raise grades, reduce flood storage, redirect drainage, alter wetland hydroperiods, or damage protected root zones and belowground ecological networks.

Test before disturbing former golf-course soil

  • A resident filing reports an FDACS inquiry concerning alleged Target 6 Plus or related arsenical-herbicide use. Save Tarpon Woods has not independently verified that an inquiry remains open or identified an official disposition; no reviewed source establishes that Target 6 Plus was applied at this site or that the site is currently contaminated.
  • Require qualified environmental investigation, systematic and targeted sampling, planting-location testing, waste characterization, worker and neighborhood protections, and lawful transport and disposal when triggered by test results.
  • Provide certified expected and reasonably foreseeable worst-case costs rather than leaving cleanup risk with residents or the public.

Protect the project from default or abandonment

  • Require recorded ownership and easement instruments, a project-delivery and quality-assurance plan, qualified staffing, independent verification, and a replacement-manager process.
  • Require a fully funded, irrevocable trust, escrow, bond, letter of credit with standby trust, or stronger authorized combination adequate for corrective work and management in perpetuity.
  • Withhold credits until prerequisites are satisfied and preserve District authority to suspend releases, draw dedicated funds, intervene after default, and require restoration.

Letter dated August 27, 2026. This is resident advocacy and technical comment, not a SWFWMD finding, completeness decision, or permit action.